![]() |
| Justice not served: Cousins Piya (left) and Prithep Sosothikul with a picture of their late grandmother, Boonsom Boonyanit. |
The Sunday Star
by Roger Tan
The police have to explain their tardiness in investigating the most infamous land forgery case in Malaysia.
This is a heart-rending story, a story about an incessant quest for justice by three generations of a Thai family.
It
all happened on Dec 12, 1956 when a Thai of Chinese origin, Sie Guan
Tjang @ Sie Hang Bok, purchased two pieces of land for investment – Lots
3606 and 3607 of Mukim 18 at Tanjung Bungah, Penang (“the said lands”).
During
his lifetime, Sie visited Penang very often with his Thai wife, Boonsom
Boonyanit, also known as Sun Yok Eng. They loved Penang and her people
so much that they had intended to build their retirement home on the
said lands. On Jan 18, 1967, the two lots of land were transferred to Boonsom
by way of a memorandum of transfer (“Form 14A”).
Under section
81(3) of the National Land Code (Penang and Malacca Titles) Act 1963
(Act 518), Form 14A was then treated more or less as proof of ownership
over the said lands. Section 92 of Act 518 also provides that pending
the issuance of a final title, an advance certificate of title (“ACT”)
would be issued. Since Jan 18, 1967, Boonsom had been at all times in
possession of the Form 14A apart from faithfully paying all the quit
rents and assessments due on the said lands.
Some time in June 1989, Boonsom’s eldest son, Phiensak Sosothikul, chanced upon an advertisement in a Thai newspaper, Thairat,
dated June 11, 1989, which was inserted by a law firm from Penang,
Messrs Khor, Ong & Co (“KOC”). The advertisement requested that any
person who had any right to the said lands or any heir to Boonsom
residing at a house No. 87, Cantonment Road, Penang, Malaysia to contact
KOC. The court was later told that when Boonsom’s accountant did
contact KOC, the latter could not give any useful information.
Boonsom
then engaged the law firm, Messrs Lim Kean Siew & Co (“LKSC”) to
conduct investigations which revealed that the said lands had been
fraudulently transferred by an impostor claiming to be Boonsom to Adorna
Properties Sdn Bhd, then known as Calget Sdn Bhd (“Adorna”) on May 24,
1989.
Boonsom then sued for the return of the said lands. The
Penang High Court ruled in favour of Adorna on April 28, 1995. On
appeal, the Court of Appeal in its judgment dated March 17, 1997
reversed the High Court’s decision. Adorna then appealed, and the
Federal Court comprising Eusoff Chin, Wan Adnan Ismail and Abu Mansor
Ali allowed Adorna’s appeal in its judgment dated Dec 13, 2000 and
pronounced in open court on Dec 22, 2000 (“Adorna Judgment”). Sadly,
Boonsom had already passed away on May 23, 2000.
Boonsom’s second
son, Kobchai Sosothikul, being the representative of her estate,
soldiered on and filed two separate motions to the Federal Court for
review of the Adorna Judgment.



